Category Archives: Blog

We’re More Confident – But Why?

Yesterday, the Bloomberg Nanos Consumer Confidence survey came out and great news, apparently: We’re getting more optimistic about the economy.

So, these 1,000 respondents studied a lot of economic data first? No chance. I always wonder what the respondents base that on. My best guess is that we just respond based on our personal economy. We base it only on what’s happening in our lives. Then, the economists take the responses and work backwards in guessing why we’re more or less confident.

The government loves a higher consumer confidence level. You and me are responsible for around 70% of economic activity with our spending. If we stop, the economy crashes. If we’re confident and keep spending – it’s all good for governments and business. Not so good for our debt…

The analysts say it’s because oil is over $60 and people in the West are more confident as a result. Really? I bet very few respondents would know that. I’d bet it’s more about hanging onto their job, reading about fewer layoffs, or seeing their neighbour or kids getting at least some kind of position.

A 5.9% unemployment rate is certainly great news for anyone looking for a job in Eastern Canada. But the national unemployment rate wouldn’t make me more positive – it’d just be what’s happening in my life.

The most optimistic people are in Quebec. The survey people think it’s partly because of foreign buyers now going into Montreal. Well, that happened so recently, there’s little chance it’s in the survey results. All time low unemployment certainly helps get people a raise. So you now make $200 more a month. That’s normally enough to make someone optimistic. But our brain blocks out the fact that we need a new roof, our line of credit hasn’t shrunk in a decade, and every day the car starts is a miracle.

That’s a province with massive infrastructure problems, debt, and corruption. The government is doing well because we Westerners send them tens of billions of dollars a year. Without that, the so-called optimism there would probably match the reality that they’re a financial basket case. If you were to send me a thousand bucks a month to band-aid my financial trouble – I’d be optimistic, too.

43% think house prices will rise in the coming year. If it’s respondents in Vancouver or Toronto, that makes sense. I don’t also mean to pour cold water on it, but the reality is that the new mortgage laws will make that next to impossible. You now need a buyer with $150,000 higher income to buy your home. Or, if you’re a buyer, you need to find a home $100,000 to $150,000 less than you could buy last year. In fact, there have already been comments from some federal government people they’d be prepared to re-visit these changes if need be.

And if optimism is high now – wait until the numbers come out after recreational drugs are legal. The high could be much higher…

Careful With Car Rental Pre-Paids

If you’re flying anywhere, it’s probably a fair guess that most people rent a vehicle at least once a year or so. For me, it’s more like 15 times.

If you’re ever on one of the car rental sites, you’ll see a new category: Pay now or pay later. You now have the option of pre-paying at the time you reserve it. It’ll give you a 5 to10% discount. But, and it’s a big but: I’ve rented a vehicle 11 times in the last three months. In EVERY case, the rental rates dropped between my first reservation and the week prior to my trip.

All I did was cancel my reservation and make a new one at the lower rate. You can’t do that if you’ve prepaid with no refund or cancellation option. It would have cost me roughly $350 extra to pre-pay, instead of a saving.

If you’re close to the rental date, it might make sense. A month or two out, you’re likely way better off re-shopping over pre-paying! The best example was when I was in Kelowna last month. I had made a reservation with one of the Kelowna airport national chains. The rate was $48 base rate. The week before I re-checked at Hotwire.com I could get it for $26 a day. When I booked and paid it, the confirmation was for the same company I had booked direct with! What a rip off! Hotels and car rental places say come to our website directly for guaranteed lowest rates. Big fat lie! Even with the hotwire markup, it was almost 50% cheaper through a third party and not their site! Be careful when comparison shopping!

Turning 60 Soon?

If you’re 60 or turning 60 soon, you have a big decision to make about your banking.

Most banks have changed giving you free banking to age 65. The last one was the Royal – it’s covered in the banking chapter of the Money Tools book.

But credit unions are almost all still free at age 60. So your decision is whether a loyalty to your bank (that will never be reciprocated) is worth over $1,500 in fees for five more years…

Our Irrational Financial Choices

Something went wrong last week: I didn’t get the Nobel prize for Economics for some reason… for something I’ve been bugging people about for more than two decades.

All economic models ever taught and used by businesses were based on the fact that we make rational economic and purchase choices. It’s been used forever to explain how markets work to allocate resources and to set prices.

This years, the Nobel prize went to behavioural economist Richard Thaler. He proved that we don’t actually make rational buying decisions at all. We constantly make irrational and illogical choices that are totally opposed to our financial well being. There: It’s the reason we’re mostly broke. We make stupid financial choices that sabotage our savings and put us into debt!

The best example is from the U.S., where employees have always had the chance for payroll deduction, very often with matching employer money for retirement savings. Yet, very few did it. That totally sabotaged their retirement savings. When the law was changed that it’s done automatically, but you can certainly opt out with one signature, very few people did! In just a few years, it’s created $30 billion of retirement savings!

The best destructive example is someone who emailed me that they “had” to buy a new vehicle because they had a new baby. Nice try. The old one was four years old and just fine. The baby was just the final excuse to trade up.

If you’ve ever heard the saying that’s been around forever that “so and so could sell a fridge to an Eskimo”, isn’t THAT the person who should have gotten the Nobel prize? Or the first person selling pots to cook food in by selling the choice of two colors?

More New Mortgage Tightening Rules

Three times the Federal government has tightened up mortgage lending rules for those people with less than 20% down payment. Now they’ve made it much harder for those of us with equity of more than 20% to re-mortgage or to buy a new home as well.

I’ll join the economists, along with the Fraser Institute, who think this new stress-test has gone way too far, and will have a measurable impact on home sales, and most of us being able to qualify for a mortgage starting January 1st.

Here’s the new rule: No matter how much you earn or how much down-payment you have, you need to qualify for an arbitrary five-year posted rate. Right now you can get a 5-year rate of under 2.8% but you still need to qualify for the 4.9% sticker rate. Stupid but true. A family making $100,000 with 20% down can afford a home worth $726,000 right now. With the new rule, that same family’s purchasing power is down to a $570,000 home. That’s a $150,000 lesser mortgage or lower priced home.

Yet this is a family that has over 20% equity and certainly not someone who’s in any trouble of being foreclosed on. Still, they have to qualify on the “pretend” rate of 4.9%. That would be SEVEN rate increases, and that’s something we’ll never see!

If you’re not making $100,000 and are not totally debt free, you’re never going to qualify for any home that’s even the average price! In my case, I need to sell my home and down-size. But if I do that, I no longer qualify for a new mortgage. Talk about putting huge numbers of people into a total lose-lose catch-22!

Right now, you can still avoid this so-called B-20 rule with your credit union because they aren’t governed by federal regulations. But it appears that most of them will end up matching the rules at some point. All I can suggest starting January is to call a number of credit unions and ask. You don’t need to go in or fill out an application. Just ask if they’re also using the B-20 regulations.

Loyalty is Dead: This Time it’s Aeroplan

We talked last year about loyalty programs. On average we’re in a dozen programs and active in about eight.

But, if you’ve noticed, almost all of them aren’t loyal to you. Their way of getting points, freebies, dollars, or whatever are harder to get, PLUS the redemptions keep getting further and further away from happening. It’s more of a game that you’re going to lose beyond a free toaster or something minor. Yet, we’re hooked and stay loyal, despite all the evidence that we’re not getting much of a reward for it – and often for overpaying when another company is often cheaper to deal with.

The newest is a twist where the company who wants your business isn’t even loyal to their loyalty company! If you remember back, it wasn’t that long ago that Air Canada was on the verge of bankruptcy. At that time, they sold their frequent flyer miles program for some big money.

Aimia is the company that owns and runs the Aeroplan frequent flyer loyalty program. They also manage those of Nordstrom, and other companies from Europe to the Middle East.

They have five million of us Canadians as members who hold over 200 billion miles. The company itself, buys 700 million dollars of tickets from Air Canada a year. But now Air Canada is dumping the company that bailed them out to start their own loyalty program again. Needless to say, the stock was down over 76% after the announcement.

Aeroplan is done as of 2020. So the five million of us will start to get greatly reduced rewards. After all, what’s Aimia’s reason for keeping us excited when Air Canada is yanking us away from the program. By the end of next year, there’s no point chasing points that you’re not likely to get any benefit from. On my to-do list is to cash them all out by next year. I normally get Esso gift cards as they can turn into real cash when I gas up. Most other things are pretty marked up in value, so be careful before you press the “redeem” button. If you’re close to an airline ticket, book it as soon as you can before the points needed goes up again and again. If you’re not close – I’d recommend you don’t start the chase.

Two Insights Worth Remembering

Private used car purchasers: If you’re thinking of buying a used car in the next year, you need to know a warning from the Better Business Bureau. Hurricane flooded cars from Texas are showing up in Canada. You should, in any case, but now have to, get it inspected by a mechanic before paying for it. After the fact, when you need an out of province inspection anyway in order to register it, it’s too late and you’re out the money. A shortcut would be to pay the out of province inspection before buying and use it as your indicator of whether to buy or not. It’ll save you one step and a few bucks.

At a gas station in the US? Finally a tip I needed years ago. It would have avoided me getting a real U.S. credit card. At almost every gas station, pay at the pump requires you to enter your Zip code as a security measure. Well, us Canadians don’t have one. That means you’re going inside to pre-authorize, then gas, then back in to get your receipt for the actual total to make sure they don’t cash the full pre-authorized amount. But there’s a trick you can try that I’m told solves that: When asked for the Zip code, enter: 23400. Apparently that tells the system you’re a Canadian and that you’re good for the charge!

Financial Advisor or Adviser? It Can Cost You a Lot…and Your Cell Phone

Here’s a word that you have to know how to spell. If not, it can cost you tens of thousands of dollars. The word is advisor…or adviser. Two different ways to spell the same word and almost nobody notices the difference.

Almost all financial institutions now use this word for their formerly known as loans officers. But if you’re dealing with a financial advisor, you’re actually dealing with a sales person. If it’s advisor (with an e) it’s someone with a license, which you’ll see by their degree and designation. Those people need to act in the best interest of the client, it’s called a fiduciary responsibility.

If you’re going to buy a vehicle, a mattress, furniture, or jewelry – the items that are most expensive and/or have the largest markups – do you want to deal with a close family member or a stranger? The family member, of course. Because you can trust them a lot more than a stranger trying to close the deal and make the commission.

Banks are for parking your money and not for investing. But, since the majority of Canadians are going to ignore that fundamental advice…would you like to deal with a sales person or someone who has your best interests in mind? If you need an easy way to remember, think of the “o” in financial advisor as “oh oh…you’re about to get sold!”

The difference in your investments is whether it benefits the financial institution or you. And that can quickly add up in the front or back loaded mutual funds, the fees, the type of investments, the person’s investment knowledge, and the type of investments they recommend based on your needs and goals…or maybe on an internal bonus system or steering you into their managed funds. If it’s a GIC or something basic, it won’t matter. If it’s more than that – it matters a lot. Don’t spend a ton of time looking for the advisers (with an e) as they’re less than 7% of those jobs and it’s 93% plus that are sales people on commission.

 

Great news: The regulators of our phone services have come into the 20th century and have now made cars legal to operate in Canada. Yes, that’s rather sarcastic. But the point is that regulators move at the speed of glaciers. Unfortunately, that’s almost always to the detriment of our wallets and finances!

The Canadian CRTC has now mandated that phones be sold unlocked so you’re not a hostage to your current cell provider. That’s for new purchases starting in December. And current customers have the right to have their phones unlocked so they can fire their cell provider and become a free agent.

Plus, on family plans, the person who pays the bills now has to OK any data overages. You’d think that’s common sense, but ask the thousands of parents who have paid hundreds or literally $2,000 or more for data overages when their kids have just been able to press the “yes” button.

Sears, Amazon and Why We Can’t Do Our Own Investing

Ever wonder why retailers aren’t doing so well? Here’s a huge reason for it: Traditional retailers such as Sears, The Bay, Macy’s and the likes take 9 to 13 months to get a new clothing line from concept to production and into their stores to sell. Zella is a company with an extensive line of clothing. They can get an idea to production and into stores inside of two weeks! Two weeks versus a year. Wonder no longer why traditional retailers are fading quickly.

On the upside, Thursday Amazon announced they’d be selling Kenworth appliances online. Yes, Sears does have stuff people want – but now it’ll be online and in the U.S. only for the time being.

That announcement also shows why you and I really can’t do our own investing very well: When Amazon announced they’d be selling Kenworth, the stocks of other appliance retailers and manufacturers dropped by $12.5 billion collectively. From Best Buy to Whirlpool, Lowe’s, Home Depot, and the likes their stocks took a big hit. Now you and I may have figured out in a few days that, instead of Kenworth being gone, they’re now going to be a major player with Amazon behind them, but the Bay and Wall Street computers made the sell moves within a minute…

Speaking of investments, I’m going to make a bold prediction if you remember that I’m not an economist: The Bank of Canada can’t and won’t raise rates again until the U.S. does. The rate increase two weeks ago was based on thinking the U.S. would do one, too and they didn’t. The dollar is now way too high for our exporters and getting the dollar down is the main objective of the Bank of Canada. So they can’t do another increase, even if they wanted to, until the U.S. starts to raise them again.

Bad for savers, good for borrowers to get another reprieve…

Canada Post Financial and Eating Out at Lunch

Senator Elizabeth Warren has been promoting this idea for over a year in the U.S. But what about here in Canada? The post office is not exactly a growing business, but a very necessary one that isn’t making money, keeps charging more, and isn’t going to go away in our lifetime.

The post office is already a vast network of locations all across the country. They’re in remote areas that aren’t even serviced by a bank. Why can’t the post office sell prepaid debit cards, do cheque cashing, incoming and outgoing foreign money transfers to relatives, small loans and the likes?

Even if it just re-directs 10% of people from payday lenders or cheque cashing places it would save Canadians billions of dollars, rescue the post office and a ton of jobs there, become really convenient for people, and a new revenue stream.

 

Last year (2016) there were 430 million fewer lunchtime restaurant visits in the U.S. It has to be true in Canada, too, judging by the vast number of lunch ads from Boston Pizza to Subway, Tim’s and others. That’s a lot less eating out, or is it? Are we still buying at the lunch places but having desktop meals? That’s the slang for eating at your desk.

If you’re someone who has cut down, what I want to know is whether that money is getting saved, used to pay down bills, or just leaking out into some other “mystery” spending the rest of the week, in whatever, instead of food at lunch. Just because we eat out less, doesn’t mean we’re actually saving anything…